Madhav Singh, a zamindar, leaves behind plenty of his assets for the family. After his demise, his sons, Arjun and Raman, find themselves in a disagreement. Arjun decides to sell his share of the property and move out of the village. However, Raman is not convinced by his brother’s decision and is determined to keep their father's home intact. As both are unable to reach an agreement, they turn to legal measures to resolve their dispute.

So, how did both the brothers resolve their property conflicts? 99acres explains property dispute cases between brothers and Indian law for property distribution for such cases.

What are property dispute cases between brothers?

Property disputes between brothers can arise from various issues related to ownership, inheritance, and division of property. These disputes can be emotionally charged and complex, often requiring legal intervention. Some of the common instances include:

Disputes over ancestral property

Ancestral property disputes occur when brothers disagree over the division or use of property inherited from their forefathers. This property type is passed down through generations, and each brother has a legal right to a share. Problems arise when no clear documentation or agreement exists on property distribution. Misunderstandings and disagreements over the rightful shares can lead to conflicts.

Disputes over jointly owned property

Jointly owned property disputes happen when brothers own property together but cannot agree on its management, use, or division. These properties are often purchased together or inherited, each brother having a defined share. Conflicts may arise when one brother wants to sell or develop the property while the other does not.

Disputes over inheritance

Inheritance disputes occur when brothers disagree over the distribution of property left by a deceased family member. These disputes often arise from unclear or contested Wills, unequal asset distribution, or claims.

Ways to resolve property dispute cases between brothers

Property disputes between brothers can be resolved in several ways. Here are some simple steps that can resolve property disputes between brothers:

Communicate openly: Both parties should openly communicate their concerns, needs, and expectations. This will help in understanding the root cause of the problem.

Review legal documents: Collect all relevant documents related to the property such as Wills, deeds, and family records. Each party should understand their rights and shares as stated in these documents.

Seek mediation: A neutral third party, such as a mediator, should be involved if talking does not resolve the issue. They generally help people reach a common consensus without going to court.

Legal action: If everything else fails, the brothers may need to seek legal counsel, who can help them understand their legal rights. They can consult a lawyer specialising in property disputes and represent them in court if necessary.

Also read: How to prevent sale of disputed property in India?

Indian law for property distribution between brothers

In India, the distribution of property between brothers is governed by several laws. The primary laws include the Transfer of Property Act 1882 and various succession laws.

Transfer of Property Act, 1882

The Transfer of Property Act of 1882 is a key law regulating property transfer in India. This act defines how property can be transferred from one person to another. It includes rules about selling, gifting, leasing, and mortgaging a property.

Succession laws

In India, succession laws provide clear guidelines for inheritance according to religious and cultural practices. Some common succession laws are as follows:

Hindu Succession Act, 1956: This law applies to Hindus, Buddhists, Jains, and Sikhs. It outlines how the property of a deceased person should be distributed among their heirs. It includes rules for both ancestral and self-acquired property.

Indian Succession Act, 1925: This law applies to Christians and Parsis. It specifies how property should be divided among the legal heirs of the deceased.

Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937: This law applies to Muslims and defines how property should be inherited according to Islamic principles.

In a nutshell, property disputes between brothers can be resolved through mediation or legal means. Several laws are in place to provide legal assistance and resolution for these disputes. However, clear communication should be the first step when addressing a property dispute with a family member or brother. With the right approach, families can settle these issues and save their relationships as well. 

 

See our latest webstory on How to resolve property dispute cases between brothers? Find out here!